
…and we all like it rubbed-down and slathered in sauce. We blindly road-tested 42 barbecue sauces and 26 rubs with a panel of barbecue lovers that included a steakhouse chef and a Memphis native; then, we took a break from beer reviewing to share our tasting notes on every finger-lickin’ one.
Today, we tackle the sauces. Check back next week when we rundown the rubs.
Bear-Man Growlin’ Grizzly Barbecue Dipping Sauce
Akin to chili, this sauce exudes tempting onion and smoke smells. Very ketchupy in texture and flavor, tangy and sweet notes hit you first, followed by spicy notes at the end of the swallow. Definitely a better dipping sauce than a slathering sauce, we like how this tastes on crunchy char.
Big Bob Gibson Bar-B-Q Championship Red Sauce
Brick-red in color with black pepper freckles, Big Bob’s award-winning sauce pleased our panel: Certainly tangy but sweet on the sides of the tongue, this smooth, thin sauce displayed nice tomato tastes, just enough smoke and a Worcestershire hint. What it lacks in heat, it makes up for in flavor.
Big Bob Gibson Bar-B-Q Original White Sauce
White barbecue sauce is a phenomenon of the South, and we can see why: Big Bob Gibson’s version smells a bit like ranch or Caesar dressing, and tastes similar — tangy and extremely peppery. It’s not traditional barbecue, but this colorless version is excellent as a burger topping, salad dressing, coleslaw binder, and chicken-finger dipping sauce.
Big Nugg BBQ Co. Q Sauce
A nice (but not complex) version of a standard sauce, Q sauce is garlicky with hints of onion. It’s sweet to be sure, but the sweetness deep and natural — more fruity than saccharine. A solid all-purpose barbecue sauce with just a bit of heat.
Big Nugg BBQ Co. Southwest Chipotle Q Sauce
Dark maroon with very tiny chunks, we didn’t expect such a dynamic taste from this sauce: Honey sweet, packed with peppers and definitely citrusy (that’s orange and tangerine concentrate talking), this chipotle version also presents earthy undertones that nicely round out the spashier flavors.
Big Tex Morgan’s Boot Kickin’ Chipotle BBQ Sauce
Oniony sweetness and crunchy chipotle and onion chunks make this sauce a winner for a nice slab of juicy, charred meat you don’t need to drown in sauce. It smells smoky, woody, and tangy with a little heat, and the taste offers a sweet-versus-spicy play and a perky freshness.
Big Tex Morgan Western BBQ Sauce (DRAFT Favorite)
Tangy, slightly smoky, and oniony-sweet, Big Tex Morgan (a real dude, by the way) crafts an excellent interpretation of a standard sauce. Mild spice, vine-ripened tomatoes, and crunchy fresh onion chunks combine in a well-thickened sauce that sits just right on brisket. One taster called it “a good brisket sauce.”
Buy it: $5, www.bigtexmorganbbqsauce.com
Black Swan Beso del Fuego (DRAFT Favorite)
Made with pureed vegetables and a tomato base, this super-fresh chunky sauce would be a dead ringer for salsa if not for its brown sugar, salt, and Worcestershire notes. The intense heat is utterly flawless; a bright, hot mix of peppers and garlic builds nicely but never scorches the palate.
Buy it: www.blackswancompany.com
Bone Suckin’ Sauce (DRAFT Favorite)
Bone Suckin’s deceptively thin Carolina-style sauce packs in tangy honey, sweet brown sugar, onion, and garlic flavors with the slightest hint of horseradish. “The apple cider vinegar base gives it a smooth, refreshing flavor,” said one tester. “It’s perfect for barbecue on a hot day.”
Buy it: www.bonesuckin.com
Captain Curt’s Famous Boss Sauce (Mild)
You know a Captain Curt’s sauce as soon as it hits your lips: There’s a vegetal, celery-sweet taste that’s indescribably unique. Gel-like in appearance, the sauce offers some nice floral and black pepper tastes that complement the celery tones well, plus a kick from the pickling spice in addition to all of the usual barbecue tastes you expect from a quality sauce. Make no mistake: This sauce is different, but delicious.
Captain Curt’s Famous Boss Sauce (Hickory)
We didn’t quite get the smoke in this Boss Sauce adaptation; it tastes just as good as Captain Curt’s mild sauce, but our panel subtracted points for the undelivered promise of hickory flavor.
Captain Curt’s Famous Boss Sauce (Hot)
We liked this hotter version of Captain Curt’s Boss Sauce a bit better than the original; the extra heat makes a nice contrast to those vegetal celery flavors, without taking control of the palate.
Captain Curt’s Famous Boss Sauce (Lemon Honey)
Similar in its taste profile to the Captain’s original sauce, the Lemon Honey version has a slight but bright addition of — you guessed it! — lemon and honey flavors that aren’t detectable on pork or beef, but make a good showing on chicken.
Cowtown Night of the Living Bar-B-Q Sauce (DRAFT Favorite)
Puréed chipotle peppers lend fresh, high heat to this rich, dark sauce; smoke, anchovies, and brown sugar tone down the spice and add some depth. “I’m surprised how sweet it is,” said one panelist. “I thought it’d be heavy on the smoke since it’s so brown, but it’s really well-balanced.”
Buy it: www.cowtownbbq.com
Kansas City’s Cowtown Bar-B-Q Sauce
This Cowtown offering fell just short of scoring within our six favorites; it’s a pleasantly tangy standard sauce that ups the ante with perfectly balanced ketchup, vinegar, and smoke tastes and a body thick enough to cling to a rack of ribs. It can tackle beef, but its also light enough so as to not drown chicken.
D.L. Jardine’s Killer Barbecue Sauce
This sauce looks and smells like parmesan-dusted marinara sauce, and lacks the depth we hoped for in a condiment called “killer.” Hot-heads will like the jalapeno and black pepper notes, but the bit of smoke in the flavor made our panel wish for more intensity.
D.L. Jardine’s 5-Star Barbecue Sauce
A sure crowd-pleaser, 5-star has something for everyone: just the right amount of wood and smoke notes, a smooth body, complex peppery spice, hints of mustard, and Worcestershire and a smooth but weighty body. There’s no major kick to it, but the sauce is a good match for the deep, meaty flavors of beef and pork ribs.
D.L. Jardine’s Mesquite Barbecue Sauce
The thickest sauce we tried, this woodsy sauce offered up a bevy of well-done mesquite flavor that wasn’t over-the-top; our panel’s only complaint was the pasty, slightly grainy texture.
D.L. Jardine’s Texas Pecan Barbecue Sauce
This creamy sauce smells wonderfully nutty, like pecan pie, with a nice wash of molasses. The taste evokes visions of maple-syrupy waffles, with notes of cracked pepper. Our panel gave it mixed reviews; one tester didn’t like the lack of traditional barbecue flavors, while another said, “I’d like to use it on grilled trout or salmon, rather than the usual barbecue meats.”
D.L. Jardine’s Chik’n Lik’n Bar-B-Q Grill and Oven Sauce (DRAFT Favorite)
Part barbecue, part lemon-pepper brilliance, this mustard-based sauce perked up our testers’ palates: Hot pepper sauce gives the blend a tart medium spice, while a nice douse of lemon juice provides a sourness that penetrates chicken on the grill and makes for an unmatched dipping sauce for chicken fingers.
Buy it: www.jardinefoods.com
Donya Marie’s Sassy Fiesta Dark Chocolate Barbecue Sauce
Puddinglike in look and texture, this barbecue-chocolate hybrid received mixed reviews from our tasters. Some loved the black-pepper aroma, and how smooth chocolate undertones rounded out the spice; others were wary of the thick mouthfeel. Bottom line: Skip it on chicken and pork loin, but use it on beef, or as a rib-meat dipping sauce.
Dr. Pepper Sweet and Kickin’ BBQ Sauce
We were skeptical of this novelty sauce, but were blown away by its sticky-sweet goodness. It smells exactly how you’d expect a Dr. Pepper barbecue sauce to smell: Like the famous cola, molasses, and smoke. The taste is a thought-provoking blend of Dr. P and tomato, and though we wouldn’t brush it on our tri-tip, we will dip our chicken fingers in it. One panelist pondered, “Maybe 23 flavors is just too much for one barbecue sauce.”
Everett and Jones Super Q Barbeque Sauce (Mild)
Smoky to the core, this sauce from barbecue powerhouse Everett and Jones is wooden to the core. It shows some brown sugar notes, but smoke is the main event in this mild sauce.
Everett and Jones Super Q Barbeque Sauce (Medium)
Nearly identical in flavor to its mild cousin, this medium version gets a kick from cayenne, but never overcomes its heavy smoke.
Everett and Jones Super Q Barbeque Sauce (Hot)
Red pepper flakes add a heap of spice to this smoke monster; we’re still yearning for that ketchupy sweetness or a hint of tang.
Jack Daniel’s Hickory Brown Sugar Barbecue Sauce
We wanted to like this sauce, really, but the liquid smoke flavor was just too overwhelming. There are nice wood and molasses notes, but as one taster noted, “The whiskey flavor is disturbing.”

Mad Dog Original BBQ Sauce
Smoke lovers will like this peppery sauce, although it wasn’t balanced enough to earn high marks from our tasters. Crafted with molasses, cayenne pepper, and aged tamari, there’s a nice flavor base, but a thick mouthfeel and hickory notes take away from the sauce’s depth.
Mama Hairston’s Sweet n’ Hot BBQ Sauce
A bit of spice and caramelized onion characterize this deliciously well-balanced sauce. A nice blend of tomato, vinegar, and brown sugar, one panelist called it pleasantly “sloppy joe-ish.”
Melanie’s Big Acres Gourmet Sauce Chipotle Maple BBQ
A nice specialty sauce that doesn’t deviate too far from the norm, Melanie’s maple creation is a robust blend of smoke and chipotle spice that’s excellent on pork. Chock-full of maple flavor and supplemented by brown sugar, honey, and peppery tastes, the sauce is richly flavored but overly so.
Ole Ray’s Apple/Cinnamon Barbeque Sauce (DRAFT Favorite)
So good, you could eat spoonfuls straight from the jar. Sweet, almost candylike apple-pie flavors (thanks to apple jelly, caramel, and cinnamon) mix with black pepper and smoke for an autumnal glaze you’ll want to smear on everything from pork ribs to shrimp.
Buy it: www.olerayssauces.com
Oregon Dan’s Original BBQ Sauce
Adapted from a recipe by Dan’s great aunt and produced in small batches, Oregon Dan’s is gluten-free and contains “a taste of Hawaii in each bottle” — which means it includes pineapple and pineapple juice in each bottle. It’s an acquired taste to be sure, and not your typical barbecue sauce; the acidity plays nicely on pork, but we miss those traditional barbecue flavors.
Oregon Dan’s BBQ Sauce
Basically Oregon Dan’s Original with a bit more heat. We like the upped spice, but still yearn for those basic barbecue tastes — ketchup, Worcestershire, vinegar, and peppers.
Oregon Dan’s Habanero Hot BBQ Sauce
This sauce’s flavor profile aligns perfectly with Oregon Dan’s Original sauce, but with jacked-up heat from habanero peppers. It’s an island-tinged scorcher!
Oregon Dan’s Apricot BBQ Sauce
Again, the flavor profile is similar to the rest of Oregon Dan’s lineup, but with a bit of apricot in the mix. We wish the apricot were more prominent in the sauce; the sauce was still a tad weak for our panel’s tastes.
5-0 BBQ Outlaw Honey Hot BBQ Sauce
Perfect on pork loin, Outlaw Honey Hot displays a definite whiskeylike, white wine-ish note, plus a bright, sweet, honey-citrus taste that isn’t cloying.
Pain is Good Batch #218 Southern Style
With spice so bright it shines, this “southern style” sauce strikes a good balance between hot and sweet. Honey gives it some sugar, but pepper flakes lend it some seriousness. A wonderful consistency allows just a bit of the sauce to cling to the tongue.
Pain is Good Batch #37 Garlic-que
A huge whiff of garlic escapes from the bottle — just a hint of the crunchy garlic chunks inside. Tangy garlic trumps the sauce’s other tastes, though there’s a nice spice in the background. Some panelists wished more traditional barbecue flavors would show through, but the garlic lovers in the bunch liked this change of pace.
Pain is Good Batch #114 Jamaican Jerk
A solid showing, but not enough big jerk flavors to make our heads turn. One taster noted, “I’d use this on chicken regularly, but if I’m bringing out the big guns for a barbecue, I’ll use something more powerful.”
Red’s White Sauce
White barbecue sauce is a love-it-or-hate-it condiment — but if you love it, Red’s is a must-try. It looks akin to Caesar dressing, but thicker and darker; the taste is loaded with black pepper and nice Worcestershire notes, plus a bit of tang from white wine.
Scorned Woman Fiery Barbeque Sauce
You can smell heat from the bottle; indeed, this was the hottest sauce our panel tasted (one tester noted “My face is sweating!”). Remarkably, all that heat doesn’t burn off the vinegar, hickory, and tang that makes this sauce excellent. Opaque and brown with a bit of chunkiness, Scored Woman controls its heat well and adds a kick to whatever’s on the grill.
Stone Levitation Ale Barbeque Sauce
Sauce that smells like a brewery is okay by us. It tastes fresh, and the beer is apparent, but isn’t overkill; rather, tangy and spicy notes plus flavorful chunks balance out the brew.
Stone Smoked Porter & Pasilla Pepper BBQ Sauce
The good: This sauce is expertly spiced, with superb heat and flavor from pasilla peppers that wakes up the palate. The bad: There is such a thing as too much smoke; a dark, smoky bitterness begins to overwhelm that lovely spice after a few bites. A good pick for char-lovers.